Judges inspect Lindela as asylum fairness under scrutiny

Judges inspect Lindela as asylum fairness under scrutiny

High Court bench tours detention facility amid scrutiny of migrant treatment

The conditions under which asylum seekers are held, and the fairness of the system that decides their futures, took centre stage this week when a full bench of the Gauteng Division of the High Court visited the Lindela Repatriation Centre ahead of a ruling in a case concerning the detention of undocumented migrants seeking asylum.

The Inter-Ministerial Committee on Migration has welcomed that visit, calling it an opportunity for the judiciary to see operations at the centre first-hand. Speaking at an IMC media briefing on Thursday, committee chairperson and Justice and Constitutional Development Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi said the committee appreciated the initiative undertaken by the full bench, led by Justice Ledwaba, to visit the facility on Wednesday.

For the public, the significance lies in what the visit signals about accountability. The committee reaffirmed that immigration management must be exercised within South Africa’s constitutional and legislative framework, including compliance with court orders and applicable international obligations. Kubayi also confirmed that the IMC continues to closely track court cases affecting asylum seekers, refugees and immigration enforcement across the country, since the outcomes of those proceedings shape how ordinary people are treated at every stage of the system.

The oversight visit comes at a moment when the legal framework itself is being tested. Government is actively participating in High Court proceedings in Gauteng aimed at resolving a series of conflicting judgments on immigration enforcement, a tangle that has created uncertainty for both officials and the people subject to the system. Kubayi recalled that government had previously indicated its intention to approach the Constitutional Court for a supervisory order in the Scalabrini Judgment, and said that process now runs parallel to the current High Court proceedings.

“We are pleased to report that government is fully engaged in the process of arguments currently underway in the Gauteng Division of the High Court to resolve the conundrum of the said conflicting judgments,” she said.

A coordinated whole-of-government approach is underway, with formal legal submissions made by the Department of Justice, the National Prosecuting Authority, the Department of Home Affairs, the South African Police Service and the Border Management Authority. Kubayi said government will await the outcome of the High Court process before proceeding with its intended action in the Constitutional Court.

Meanwhile, the committee has welcomed the commencement of Phase One of the Department of Home Affairs’ online asylum seeker registration system on 10 November 2026. The reform aims to modernise immigration administration, reduce delays, address backlogs and strengthen the integrity of asylum management, changes that bear directly on how quickly and fairly applicants move through the process.

The initial phase introduces online registration while retaining in-person biometric verification at designated refugee reception centres. According to Kubayi, the digital reform is intended to improve administrative efficiency and strengthen accountability in the processing of asylum applications.

She was careful, however, to set out the limits of the new system. It does not automatically confer refugee status, nor does it exempt applicants from the requirements of South African law. Applicants remain subject to verification, screening and adjudication. Government, she said, remains alert to the risks of fraud, identity misrepresentation, false information and attempts to exploit weaknesses in the asylum application process.

“Digitalisation must strengthen immigration control, not create new opportunities for abuse,” Kubayi said, adding that the committee supports continued monitoring of the system, strengthened fraud-prevention measures and appropriate action against individuals or syndicates seeking to manipulate asylum procedures. The registration system forms part of the Department of Home Affairs’ broader modernisation efforts, which also include improved services for South Africans.

On the question of court processes, the Minister emphasised that any necessary policy or administrative adjustments must be undertaken lawfully. The relocation of the Refugee Reception Offices has also started in earnest. The first phase is the establishment of a temporary office at Beit Bridge, which will be operational by 11 December 2026. A visit by the Minister of Home Affairs and IMC members to the reception office is planned ahead of a proposed visit by the President at a date still to be confirmed.

Q&A

Why did a full bench of the Gauteng Division of the High Court visit Lindela Repatriation Centre?

The visit, led by Justice Ledwaba and made ahead of a ruling in a case on the detention of undocumented migrants seeking asylum, allowed judges to see operations at the centre first-hand before deciding the matter.

What did the Inter-Ministerial Committee on Migration say about the visit?

The committee welcomed it as an opportunity for the judiciary to see the facility first-hand. Chairperson Mmamoloko Kubayi said the IMC appreciated the initiative and reaffirmed that immigration management must stay within South Africa's constitutional and legislative framework, including court orders and international obligations.

What does the new online asylum seeker registration system do, and what does it not do?

Phase One, starting 10 November 2026, introduces online registration while retaining in-person biometric verification at designated refugee reception centres, aiming to reduce delays, address backlogs and strengthen accountability. It does not automatically confer refugee status and does not exempt applicants from South African law; verification, screening and adjudication still apply.

What is government doing about conflicting immigration court judgments?

Government is participating in High Court proceedings in Gauteng to resolve conflicting judgments on immigration enforcement, with formal legal submissions from the Department of Justice, the National Prosecuting Authority, the Department of Home Affairs, the South African Police Service and the Border Management Authority. It will await the outcome before proceeding with its intended Constitutional Court action on a supervisory order in the Scalabrini Judgment.