Limpopo Controversy: Why “Your View” Was Suspended on Newzroom Afrika

Published: June 2025

What Happened: A Live On-Air Incident

On Thursday, March 12, 2025, during a live broadcast of Your View, host Onkgopotse “JJ” Tabane made remarks described as disparaging toward the people of Limpopo, stating they were “higher grade” in witchcraft. These comments immediately drew criticism for being offensive and insensitive :contentReference[oaicite:2]{index=2}.

The controversial statement was delivered while discussing the ANC Youth League and COVID-19 quarantine decisions, when Tabane said: “Who bewitched these guys… they’re from Limpopo, they must have been bewitched… Limpopo specialises in higher grade witchcraft.” This remark triggered an immediate outcry from viewers and social media :contentReference[oaicite:3]{index=3}.

Newzroom Afrika Responds: Suspension and Investigation

Within hours, Newzroom Afrika issued a public statement condemning Tabane’s comments as “not aligned with the values of the channel.” The station emphasised its commitment to respecting all South African cultures and announced the immediate suspension of Your View, pending an internal review led by its editorial sub‑committee chaired by Dr. Joe Thloloe :contentReference[oaicite:4]{index=4}.

Zamahlasela Gabela, Head of Marketing & Communications, affirmed that Tabane had acknowledged his error and would issue a formal apology both on social media and during the following night’s edition of News@Prime :contentReference[oaicite:5]{index=5}.

Apology and Cultural Sensitivity

The following evening, on News@Prime, Tabane delivered a heartfelt apology. He acknowledged the remarks were “unacceptable” and “brought the channel into disrepute.” He stated: “I am truly sorry to all the people of Limpopo” and emphasised his intent to uphold journalistic respect and cultural understanding :contentReference[oaicite:6]{index=6}.

Newzroom Afrika praised his apology and welcomed its sincerity, though they maintained that the comments still warranted disciplinary review :contentReference[oaicite:7]{index=7}.

Cultural Backlash and Social Media Reactions

Social media ignited with reactions—some supported strict action, others called for understanding. On Twitter, one user declared:

“Limpopo is not a dumping site… for JJ Tabane to say live on TV that Limpopians are witches… Silimele.”

:contentReference[oaicite:8]{index=8}

Conversely, some argued the suspension was excessive. For example, Magasela Mzobe, ex‑ANC Youth leader, tweeted:

“Why investigate when he has acknowledged his mistake and apologised? Bring back the show.”

:contentReference[oaicite:9]{index=9}

Context: The Implications of On-Air Comments

Media experts emphasise that comments about witchcraft and regional stereotypes are potent and sensitive in South Africa. They can reinforce harmful perceptions and deepen cultural divisions. Limbopo, known for its rich cultural heritage, was unfairly stigmatized by Tabane’s off-the-cuff analogy :contentReference[oaicite:10]{index=10}.

As a result, this incident sparked internal dialogue at Newzroom Afrika and broader public debate about balancing editorial freedom with cultural responsibility.

Resuming “Your View”: What Followed

After expressing his apology, and upon internal review, Newzroom Afrika reinstated Your View. The decision was based on the sincerity of the apology and constructive social discourse :contentReference[oaicite:11]{index=11}.

Tabane returned on Monday, March 16, with a note of humility: “I will do better.” The broadcast resumed under heightened awareness and editorial caution to avoid future cultural missteps.

Learnings for Broadcasters and Journalists

This episode offers key lessons for media outlets in culturally complex societies like South Africa:

• Words carry weight: Jokes or cultural references can easily become harmful stereotypes.
• Swift corrective action: Newzroom Afrika’s suspension signaled accountability and reassured offended communities.
• Value-driven leadership: Editorial oversight and committee review ensured a measured response.
• Public dialogue: The event sparked necessary discussions on regional respect and inclusivity.

The Bigger Picture: Newzroom Afrika’s Editorial Standards

Newzroom Afrika, relaunched in 2019 and positioned as a fresh voice in South African television news, has consistently invested in ethical journalism. Anchors like Tabane benefit from an editorial culture overseen by an advisory committee, including respected journalists such as Dr. Joe Thloloe and editor-in-chief Njanji Chauke :contentReference[oaicite:12]{index=12}.

The network’s response reflects its commitment to impartial and culturally-aware broadcasting, essential in a diverse nation.

What’s Next?

The controversy offers an opportunity for improved cultural sensitivity training, stronger editorial safeguards, and better community engagement by broadcasters. It also aligns with growing calls for media accountability and representation :contentReference[oaicite:13]{index=13}.

For Newzroom Afrika, the incident is a reminder of the power—and responsibility—broadcast journalism wields in shaping public discourse.

For deeper insights on media ethics, visit our Media Ethics section or explore primary coverage via IOL South Africa and the official channel statement.

Share your thoughts below or follow our social media for updates on TV news standards in South Africa.